| 2021 Miss Hannah Hellyer | |
| 2020 Miss Emma Allen | 1975 Miss S Thurston |
| 2019 Miss Kerry Smith | 1974 Miss C Le Feuvre |
| 2018 Miss Kerry Smith | 1973 Miss C Le Feuvre |
| 2017 Miss Georgina Mundy | 1972 Miss C Le Feuvre |
| 2016 Miss Kerry Smith | 1971 Miss C Le Feuvre |
| 2015 Miss Aimee Paterson | 1970 Miss C Le Feuvre |
| 2014 Miss Georgina Mundy | 1969 Miss H Clifford |
| 2013 Miss Aimee Ponte | 1968 Miss P M Shepherd |
| 2012 Miss Emma Allen | 1967 Miss H Clifford |
| 2011 Miss Becky Scott | 1966 Mrs K B Bavin |
| 2010 Miss Annabel Silk | 1965 Mrs K B Bavin |
| 2009 Miss Tracey Boyes | 1964 Mrs K B Bavin |
| 2008 Miss Elizabeth Bennett | 1963 Mrs T B Green |
| 2007 Miss Elizabeth Bennett | 1962 Mrs J S F Morrison |
| 2006 Miss Kerry Smith | 1961 Mrs T B Green |
| 2005 Miss Elizabeth Bennett | 1960 Mrs T B Green |
| 2004 Mrs Sarah White | 1959 Mrs T B Green |
| 2003 Miss Kerry Smith | 1958 Mrs K B Bavin |
| 2002 Miss Kerry Smith | 1957 Mrs T B Green |
| 2001 Miss N C Booth | 1956 Miss F B Lowe |
| 2000 Miss K Taylor | 1955 Mrs K B Bavin |
| 1999 Miss K Taylor | 1954 Mrs K B Bavin |
| 1998 Miss E Weeks | 1953 Miss F B Lowe |
| 1997 Miss H M Wheeler | 1952 Mrs A C Allen |
| 1996 Mrs C M Stirling | 1951 Mrs J S F Morrison |
| 1995 Miss H M Wheeler | 1950 Mrs J S F Morrison |
| 1994 Mrs K H Egford | 1949 Mrs K B Bavin |
| 1993 Mrs K H Egford | 1948 Mrs K B Bavin |
| 1992 Miss A MacDonald | 1947 Miss M Wallis |
| 1991 Miss H M Wheeler | 1939 Miss R S Morgan |
| 1990 Miss A C MacDonald | 1938 Miss P Wade |
| 1989 Mrs S M Pickles | 1937 Miss P Wade |
| 1988 Mrs C M Stirling | 1936 Miss M Diamond |
| 1987 Mrs C M Stirling | 1935 Miss P Wade |
| 1986 Miss C M S Hayllar | 1934 Mrs Clarke |
| 1985 Mrs C M Stirling | 1933 Miss P Wade |
| 1984 Miss C H Mackintosh | 1932 Mrs W H A Hunt |
| 1983 Miss C M S Hayllar | 1931 Mrs Clarke |
| 1982 Miss A E Wells | 1930 Miss C K Uhthoff |
| 1981 Mrs S M Pickles | 1929 Mrs W H A Hunt |
| 1980 Miss C H Mackintosh | 1928 Miss C M Aitchison |
| 1979 Miss C H Mackintosh | 1927 Miss S Lamplough |
| 1978 Miss C H Mackintosh | 1926 Miss A Kyle |
| 1977 Miss C H Mackintosh | 1925 Mrs Lamplough |
| 1976 Mrs C Gibbs | 1924 Miss D Pearce |
